Hooahshirts.com | P90X | Kettlebell! | TRX| Recommended Books | Elite Rings | TAC Gear | Rocket Fins | Jet Fins | Neanderthin | Precision Nutrition

Forum Home Do not ask questions that violate OPSEC parameters. Read the ROEs and do a search before posting a question! Do not answer a question unless your information is from verified sources and accurate!

Google Search
Custom Search
Share |
SOF WODs



EXPERIENCED SPECIAL OPERATORS, FUNCTIONAL TRAINING, ELITE RESULTS!

SOFWODs
628 Griffith Rd. Unit-i
Charlotte, NC 28217
512.659.5141

SOF WODs Forum

Site Support
T-Shirts & Gear

Pararescue T-Shirt


Combat Control T-Shirt


Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#53334 - Thu Mar 11 2010 11:34 AM Too tall for pararescue?
Joshkj Offline
New Member

Registered: Mon Jan 25 2010
Posts: 7
Hey guys, been lurking on the forums for a while, reading up on every possible question I could have, but i have a somewhat oddball one. Is my height going to cause me any problems during the course of training(for para-rescue)?

I'm 6'6", and while its not as extreme as some, its still pretty tall. Im just trying to know as much as I can before hand, and be prepared for anything.

Thanks in advance!
-Josh

Top
Tap the Mouse on Google
#53336 - Thu Mar 11 2010 12:51 PM Re: Too tall for pararescue? [Re: Joshkj]
Funkmasterjay Offline
Member

Registered: Thu Mar 05 2009
Posts: 206
Loc: Puyallup, WA
Search. this was the 2nd link after searching for "Height" This may answer your question.

http://www.specialtactics.com/ubbthreads....html#Post52884


Although no height standard is established for CCT & PJ the man packable loads of minimum essential mission and survival equipment does biomechanically favor an optimal body weight and standing body height male gender body. Studies have demonstrated the rule of thumb expectation for man packable weight is: 30% of Body Weight optimum for Fighting Load. 45% of Body Weight optimum for Approach March Load. 60% body weight optimum for carriage in the sustained march load. 75% of body weight for carriage in the Existence Load. BTW, the terms fighting, assault, approach, sustained and existence define how long and far you are expected to carry this weight. The assault load=carry indefinately in addition to food and water to assault, engage and fight the enemy. The approach march load=conduct a 20-mile hike during a time frame of eight hours with the reasonable expectation of maintaining 90% combat effectiveness. The existence load=limited marching from the landing zone into a secured area. Sustained March Load - that load which may be necessary to accomplish the mission in conditions where approach marches are through terrain impassable to vehicles, or ground/air transport are not available. <--- Thus is what PJs do a lot of. If the helicopter could get to the survivor(s) we would much prefer hoisting the survivors to the express bus home. Consequently, the 5 foot 5 inch (65 inches) tall team member is working a bit harder than taller team members, when the typical weight of fighting load and other mission essential equipment is generally 50 pounds or more.
_________________________
PJ Hopeful

Top
#53337 - Thu Mar 11 2010 14:15 PM Re: Too tall for pararescue? [Re: Funkmasterjay]
Joshkj Offline
New Member

Registered: Mon Jan 25 2010
Posts: 7
Oops, searched for just "tall" before, didn't think to search height as well.

Thanks.
-Josh

Top
#54387 - Thu Jun 17 2010 11:21 AM Re: Too tall for pararescue? [Re: Joshkj]
luckdragon02 Offline
New Member

Registered: Sun Nov 30 2003
Posts: 30
Loc: UK
As a PJ i know 2 guys that are PJs that are around the 6'6" mark or so. the big issue for them has always been wieght. Parachutes have a max load that they can carry (350 Lbs or so) that includes the weight of the chute, the jumper and their gear. If you weight around 250lbs or so you will be pushing the max weight for the rig.

If you are to big to jump you cannot do the job.

Top
#54394 - Thu Jun 17 2010 14:46 PM Re: Too tall for pararescue? [Re: luckdragon02]
Yukon Online   content

Operator
*****

Registered: Wed Mar 14 2001
Posts: 927
Loc: Anchorage AK, USA
Originally Posted By: luckdragon02
If you weight around 250lbs or so you will be pushing the max weight for the rig.

If you are to big to jump you can do the job.
???? I’ve known a few 6'2" tall and taller PJs, but I don't recall them having weight pushing close to 250 pounds.

However weight suspended (jumper and equipment) under canopy not body height must not exceed the canopy's design limitations. Plus there are considerations of higher rates of descents for DZ located at elevations 5000 feet and higher above sea level and opening sequence stresses put on canopy by the weight connected to it at altitudes above 10,000 feet MSL.

Thus there are height and weight minimums and maximums unsuited for duty, rather than unfit (nothing is funnier than seeing a short person with insufficient upper body strength trying to open and close a C-130 jump door in-flight).

The standing height causes for disqualification are not specified specifically for Weapons Controllers/Directors, Combat Control, Pararescue and Air Battle Managers. However for some jobs there are sitting height and crotch height that are not compatible with operating controls and safety, especially concerning ejection egress, pertinent to ejection seat systems there is also often a body weight concern too. Some jobs even have a minimum functional reach requirement.
Quote:
AFI 48-123:

6.44.29.1.3. Flying Class II/III.
6.44.29.1.3.1. Height less than 64 inches or more than 77 inches. Waivers may be considered when appropriate based on crew position. Note: Weapons Controllers/Directors, Combat Control, Pararescue and Air Battle Managers have no standard.
6.44.29.1.3.2. Minimum functional reach for aeromedical evacuation duties is 76 inches, regardless of height.

However there are other height causes for disqualification. For instance AR 40-501 discloses:
a. Men: Height below 60 inches or over 80 inches is disqualifying.
b. Women: Height below 58 inches or over 80 inches is disqualifying.

And AFI 36-2905, Fitness Program, Chapter 6, Special Populations, 6.1. Accessions. Weight and body fat determinations (as accomplished at MEPS or other point of entry to service) remain part of accession physical standards and may also be used as entry criteria for accession training programs.

A sufficient research effort gets you eventually to DOD overweight policies and to DOD (applies to all services) service height to weight screening tables which range from a height minimum of 58 inches to a maximum of 80 inches. So 6 foot-6 inches tall weighing in at 250 pounds is certainly pushing the unsuitable to perform parachutist duties operational risk assesment window.

FYI: Maximum 80” tall person weight is 250 pounds, minimum 80” tall person weight is 173 pounds, the preferred maximum for 80” tall person is 227 pounds.

also
Quote:
DODI 1308.3:

6.1.2.3. Military Services shall extend their physical fitness programs to incorporate occupational-specific physical fitness requirements for those career fields where it is deemed necessary to ensure adequate skill, performance, and safety. This extension shall include identifying each specific physical capability needed by the occupational specialties. These additional physical fitness standards development will include a risk assessment for prevention of injuries and will reflect levels of physical abilities necessary to meet the duty demands of the occupation. Once the levels or desired physical capability are identified, physical fitness training and testing should be linked to these capabilities. Emerging training methodologies should be considered when designing the appropriate physical fitness training.

Top
#54430 - Wed Jun 23 2010 18:14 PM Re: Too tall for pararescue? [Re: Yukon]
Joshkj Offline
New Member

Registered: Mon Jan 25 2010
Posts: 7
Hrm, ok this is a little bit disconcerning considering im still training up and therefore building muscle. Im actually at 238 now since my post in march but that is mostly from me burning off excess fat. Guess its something im going to need to be really in tune with and watch closely.

Thanks guys.

Top
#54434 - Wed Jun 23 2010 23:03 PM Re: Too tall for pararescue? [Re: Joshkj]
gonnabe Offline
New Member

Registered: Thu Feb 04 2010
Posts: 26
From what I've read, bigger guys (think above the 6 foot mark) have a much higher rate of stress fractures in Indoc and BUD/S, so you might want to take the extra time to make sure you can train up to longer running distances while you can still do it safely on your own time. I'm 6' 3" and the idea of getting dropped or set back for a stress fracture is pretty scary, so at 6'6" you might want to be extra careful.

Top
#54435 - Thu Jun 24 2010 09:24 AM Re: Too tall for pararescue? [Re: gonnabe]
Dave G Offline
New Member

Registered: Wed Sep 19 2001
Posts: 61
Loc: Griffith, IN
I thought it wold be funny to show up at the chow hall in a Minny Cooper with the tallest PJ's at work that day. We all fit somehow.
Don B. =6'4", Brian B.=6'4", Mike L.= 6'2" and me the driver a lowly 5'9". In my 4yrs, There were some big PJ's around. The parachute thing is real. One size fits all. I'd jump first and these bigger guys would pass me up and hit the ground quite a bit before I would.

Top
#54500 - Wed Jun 30 2010 12:54 PM Re: Too tall for pararescue? [Re: gonnabe]
Joshkj Offline
New Member

Registered: Mon Jan 25 2010
Posts: 7
Originally Posted By: gonnabe
From what I've read, bigger guys (think above the 6 foot mark) have a much higher rate of stress fractures in Indoc and BUD/S, so you might want to take the extra time to make sure you can train up to longer running distances while you can still do it safely on your own time. I'm 6' 3" and the idea of getting dropped or set back for a stress fracture is pretty scary, so at 6'6" you might want to be extra careful.


Ive been talking extensively with my personal trainer (who also happens to be my uncle) and were both pretty confident I can cut down to 220 and still be in shape by April 2011 (when my PRK will be cleared). Thank you so much for the heads up, something I wouldn't have known otherwise, and would have just continued where I am.

Luckily even for my tall hight I have yet to have any problems knee wise or getting shin splints. Though the good chances of stress fractures is pretty scary. Are they localized to just feet and lower leg bones? And aside from strengthening excersizes and continued running, is there anything else I can do?

Top
#54516 - Thu Jul 01 2010 21:31 PM Re: Too tall for pararescue? [Re: Joshkj]
gonnabe Offline
New Member

Registered: Thu Feb 04 2010
Posts: 26
Well I'm not a doctor or trainer or anything, so you may want to confirm this independently, but as I understand it stress fractures occur predominantly in the tibia (ie shin bone, the weight bearing bone in the lower leg), although they can happen in the bones of the foot as well. I suppose technically it could happen in the femur, but that bone is already so large and strong I don't think it would be a problem. The heel area could also be a concern if you have poor form.
As for how to avoid them.. again I'm not a trainer but I think the only thing you can do is just build up the number of miles you run per week over time, eat healthy so you have all the nutrients needed to rebuild the bone, and don't run if your muscles are exhausted. Normally the stresses are absorbed partially by your muscles, and partially through the bone. As the muscle tires, the bone is forced to take more of the blow. If you build up the miles too quickly, the break down will be more and more significant, and the bone won't have time to rebuild itself in between runs. Thus stress fractures. Since taller people have more weight coming down on them each time, a drastic increase in distance will have a substantial affect on the bone. So just be careful that you don't jump straight into a million miles a week, and you should have nothing to worry about. If I had to take a guess, I would say that this probably happens most in the really muscular people that only ran 2 miles a day when training, and then once they get to Indoc the miles are upped and they just weren't ready for it. Maybe there is some genetic predisposition involved. Anyway I'm just repeating myself at this point, but you get the idea.

Top
#54522 - Sat Jul 03 2010 22:58 PM Re: Too tall for pararescue? [Re: gonnabe]
wpony2k Offline
New Member

Registered: Fri Jun 03 2005
Posts: 70
Loc: COS
Obviously luck, fate or whatever you call it has to do with whether someone gets injured,but i think maybe bigger guys should check out all the "new" science with less-is-more shoes like , nike free, 5-fingers or barefooting. Pose and/or chi-running type trainign with correct foorwear boast a dramatic reduction in running-caused injuries. Whether the claims are valid probably is case-by-case though.

Top



Moderator:  Guard MC, PJ1, PJ2PA, SN, TE, Yukon 
That Others May Live


That Others May Live is a 501 (c) (3) non-profit charitable organization established in 2002. The That Others May Live Foundation provides scholarships, family counseling, and aid to surviving children of United States Air Force (USAF) Rescue heroes who gave the ultimate sacrifice during a Rescue mission, training, or other Personnel Recovery (PR) collateral mission.

Donate to TOML through Specialtactics.com. All website donations go directly to the That Others May Live foundation.



You may also
Donate directly to TOML.

Paralyzed Veterans of America



For more than 65 years, Paralyzed Veterans of America has been dedicated to helping those who have served our country. To learn more about Paralyzed Veterans of America and their ongoing mission to change lives and build futures for all veterans with disabilities, please visit DONATE NOW AT WWW.PVA.ORG
Crossfit/SOPWOD/TRX
Who's Online
1 registered (puertocuban88), 7 Guests and 14 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
9777 Members
58 Forums
10756 Topics
50629 Posts

Max Online: 151 @ Mon Jan 17 2011 21:36 PM
Joint Tactics & Medicine

JOINT TACTICS & MEDICINE (JTM)

Celebrating 12 Years of Providing High-Level Weapons Training, Combat Medicine and Support Services to Warfighters from around the globe.

Combat Medic & TCCC training Programs
Hyper-Realistic Scenario Training Support
Advanced Operator Weapon Training Programs
Custom Tailored Training Requirements

JTM Las Vegas